A few good women By Dalton Camp
courtesy of Southam Press, Canada
Friday, May 25, 2001
Yeah! A few good women
Good men are hard to find: thankfully there's
May, McDonough et al
By Dalton Camp
I was very pleased to learn that Elizabeth
May, a doyen of the tree
huggers' movement, had ended her fast. During her self-imposed ordeal, May
drank nothing but water which, in Ontario, at least, doubles the risk of injury.
On resuming her normal caloric
regimen, she claimed at least a moral
victory in that some grudging progress was made by the federal government
and that of Nova Scotia to test the inhabitants living on the shores of a
sea of arsenic on the Isle of Cape Breton in the heart of its former coal
So, all's well that ends well; May is eating
once more and the
residents who live in the blighted area will be tested (again) and if it is
found that some are suffering, or have suffered, from poisonous substances,
steps will be taken (promise) to move them and their families to an
environmentally safe location (ASAP, mountain time).
I do not make light of the intervention of May
in seeking to get some
urgent consideration for the blighted families in Cape Breton. But we do
live in perilous times in a wider world, all but surrounded by polluters,
gun fighters, tax dodgers, countless connivers, murderers of the public
taste and the many friends of George W. Bush.
Good men are exceedingly hard to find so that
the protection of the
public virtue and its interests has been left to a few good women; May is
one of them. Let me enlarge upon this last point: May, yes and Naomi Klein,
Linda McQuaig, Maude Barlow, Alexa McDonough, in no particular order, but
enough to say that while the self-anointed arbiters of probity and propriety
can't find a way to deal with this female presence, the country would be in
far worse shape without them.
Try to name five men
Next time you're in the company of friends,
mention the five names
above (or more), then ask for the names of five men who are, at this
writing, making a similar contribution to provoking thought, discussion, and
debate on matters that matter most to the country and its people. Go ahead,
we're listening: "Well, how about David Suzuki?" OK, David
"John Manley?" Please...
"How about Whasisname ... you know, the
guy who...'' "Hey, Mother
Teresa?" She's not a Canadian and, besides, she's a woman, "Robbie
Who's the guy who plays for the Raptors?'' If Barlow would skate, her team
would be in the Stanley Cup already. Know what I am saying?
I'm asking: in this, our time of conspicuous
national need, when there
is a cry for leadership, intellect and courage, where in the hell are the
men? Why is it women are speaking out while the men remain largely silent?
Whatever the answer to the question, Canadian
women are leading the
public dialogue and shaping the public agenda, achieved without a newspaper,
or a political party, they can call their own - not even a poor man's
Business Council on National Issues - lobbying the insufferable or
indoctrinating the impenetrable.
Let us ponder where the boys are. To be nice
about it, most of them
have donated their minds to the corporate press, to the corporate think, a
systemic response to a seriously flawed economic system becoming the enemy
of the democratic state.
Max Weber saw such men imprisoned in an
"iron cage" of bureaucratic
tyranny and conformity. The system now represents an institutionalized
status quo, confirmed by the forces of globalization, sheltered and
underwritten by a co-opted and compromised political system. So it is Barlow
who sounded the alarms on Multinational Agreement on Investment, and McQuaig
who made contemporary economics comprehensible, and it was Klein who
produced her epic volume, No Logo, on the tactics and ways of consumerism,
corporatism and globalization, that has become a world bestseller.
McDonough doesn't waver
The work of these women has not only been
prodigious but fearless. The
leader of the NDP (McDonough) while embattled by her own party (that craves
respect-ability above responsibility) and who is trivialized by the same
journalists who so arduously promoted Stockwell Day, remains still a
parliamentarian singularly willing to raise issues of substance in our
There are, of course, many more women whose
energy and intellect,
grace and courage are giving leadership in a public void filled with silences.
Not that all being said and argued is all
right, but it is the
Canadian women who serve to remind us that political discourse does not need
to be the pitiable, mindless futile thing it has become today.
Dalton Camp is a political commentator.